In the Trenches: Ducks likely to waddle through rough times
CBSSports.com’s Dennis Dodd and J. Darin Darst provide analysis on college football topics.
1. With the suspension of Jeremiah Masoli and other off-field problems at Oregon, where does that put the Ducks going into next season?
DODD: After the shock wore off from Chip Kelly suspending his starting quarterback for the season, I started to think of this strictly in football terms. In football terms, this is a killer. I’m not saying Masoli shouldn’t have been suspended. He lied to his coach and the cops, that’s a deal breaker. I’m saying it was a bold step for Kelly knowing that this kind of move seriously jeopardizes the season. The coach chose character over wins. With Masoli, Oregon is top-10 team favored to win another Pac-10 title. Without him, the conference is in a jumble. The offense was tailored for him and Masoli brought that difference-maker factor. Remember when he bowled over that Oregon State defender late in the Civil War? Best guess: Kelly goes more conservati sophomores LaMichael James (suspended for the first game), Kenjon Barner and incoming five-star recruit Lache Seastrunk. While Oregon’s offense is complicated, it’s not a finesse scheme, it’s physical. There’s still 17 or 18 starters returning and the defense is good. This team could still win 10 games. The larger question is the quarterback position. Deep in his heart, I’m betting Kelly wouldn’t mind if Masoli left the program because Masoli’s situation complicates recruiting. Coaches like to target quarterback prospects as juniors (or before). What is Kelly telling quarterback recruits with Masoli due to come back in 2011 along with current third-year sophomore Darron Thomas? Without Masoli, Kelly would have an easier time targeting some of the nation’s top quarterback recruits. The battle to replace Masoli is now on. Thomas hasn’t played since 2008 while fifth-year senior Nate Costa has battled injuries and was a backup last season having started the UCLA game. No pressure, fellas. One of you is going to run a team that just went to the Rose Bowl. Yes, Oregon has run astray off the field. But it is nowhere near where Florida is in terms of law breakers. What happened at Oregon, Florida calls the month of May. OK, maybe that’s too harsh but you get the picture. If this keeps happening in Eugene, then we’ve got reason for concern. For now, I’m willing to move on.
DARST: A few months ago, I saw Oregon as the favorite in the Pac-10 but not anymore. In fact, with all the off-the-field issues this offseason, I think Oregon is in for a rough year. Having LaMichael James suspended for a game isn’t going to be that big of a deal, but suspending Masoli for the year is huge. Here is a guy who was going to be a Heisman contender. And now at quarterback? Nate Costa. Or does Chip Kelly start somebody like sophomore Darron Thomas. Costa started against UCLA and was 9 of 17 for 82 yards. Thankfully, James had 157 yards rushing and Oregon got a kickoff return for a TD and an interception return for a score in the win. The one positive is Costa or Thomas will get plenty of work leading up to the season. I commend Chip Kelly for suspending a kid who deserved to sit out the season. And Kelly didn’t let this linger on until August. He made the decision now, so the rest of the team can start looking forward. Sorry Ducks fans, I just don’t see it h at Tennessee, at USC, at California and at Oregon State.
2. Which spring game would you want to attend?
DODD: LSU, because Russell Shepard has embraced the move from quarterback to receiver. This could have been an ugly situation considering Shepard was recruited in 2009 as one of the nation’s top high school quarterbacks out of Houston. He practiced at quarterback, tailback and receiver last season and never seemed to find a position. Now that he has given up quarterback, Shepard could become the next Percy Harvin in the SEC. Shepard said he was inspired to move, in part, because Tim Tebow was called the best college player of all time but then was disparaged by NFL types. When he lined up at quarterback, it was in the Wildcat formation and Shepard didn’t attempt a pass. His mind was made up, he said, at halftime of the season’s biggest game against Florida. Jordan Jefferson threw for only 96 yards and the offense produced only a field goal in a 13-3 loss. Still, Shepard couldn’t get on the field. This makes things more comfortable for everyone. Jefferson can continue to improve at quarterback while Shepard can refine his receiving skills at slot receiver where he is listed No. 1. Here’s hoping that Les Miles shows him off in the spring game if for no other reason than to calm the masses.
DARST: Not a big fan of spring games, but how crazy is it going to be at Alabama’s spring game this year? Two years ago, 92,000 people showed up at Bryant-Denny Stadium to watch Nick Saban. What kind of attendance are they going to have this year coming off a season where the Tide won the national title? Tuscaloosa’s population is a little more than 90,000, so everywhere else but the stadium is going to be a ghost town. From a media stand point, Ohio State is the place to be. Even though this game is just a scrimmage, let’s see if the Buckeyes run their offense like they did in the Rose Bowl. To me, that is one of the biggest questions entering 2010. Ohio State is going to be ranked in everybody’s Top 3 and the pressure is going to be on Jim Tressel and Terrelle Pryor to deliver a national title. So let’s see real quickly if Pryor is going to be a lesser version of Troy Smith or will he go back to just handing the ball off and completing 8 of 17 passes a game. I want to be there to find out. That is, of course, if Tressel shows anything during the game or if Pryor even plays or faces contact after undergoing minor knee surgery in March.
3. You get to control college football for one day. What is the one thing you are doing with all this alignment talk?
DODD: This is too easy. It has to be Notre Dame to the Big Ten. The fact that Jack Swarbrick mentioned it last week at the Big East hoops tournament shows that ND’s independent status has become a front burner issue in South Bend. Swarbrick has to know that if the expansion dominoes fall right, Notre Dame could be boxed out financially and athletically. As an independent, it gets more than $10 million a year from NBC. As a Big Ten member it would more than double that take. What’s to figure out? All this tradition stuff gets old. ND is special as an independent. It would be special as a Big Ten member. Does Swarbrick want to keep playing neutral site games against the likes of Washington State or play for the Rose Bowl each year? I’m told any mating dance would have to be handled very delicately. ND rejected the Big Ten 11 years ago. On the other side, Notre Dame’s ego won’t let it go crawling to the Big Ten. Something has please pick up.
DARST: One thing? I only get to choose one? Well, I would force Notre Dame to join a conference too, but I’ll incorporate in my wish. No more BCS. Seriously, I’m so tired of this nonsense. How can every other sport have a playoff system, but college football still likes to determine its national champion by using biased humans to vote? There are a handful of ways to make 11 conference champions and f win your conference, you get a chance to play for the title. If you don’t, you have to be picked by the selection committee. Yes, the SEC isn’t the same as the Sun Belt, but guess what, we have 11 conferences in one division. In college basketball, the Big East isn’t equal to the SWAC, but guess what, both champions get in. Under my scenario, the team most likely that would have been left out of our 16-team playoff would have all with three losses. Have a complaint? Win more games. No more nonsense about kids can’t play because of exams or it will be hard for fans to travel or the bowl system will be ruined (Yeah, it’s not ruined now). I don’t hear these complaints in other sports or divisions, so I don’t want to hear it here. And on that note, sorry Notre Dame, I know the BCS has all these special rules for you to get to a major bowl, but not in my system … join a conference to be taken seriously.
4. Now that we have the bowl game in Yankees Stadium on Dec. 30, which city that doesn’t have a bowl game should have one?
DODD: Is Poughkeepsie taken? The question should be, what cities have bowl games? will be certified by the NCAA in 2010. NCAA research shows that an average of 70-72 teams have been bowl eligible in recent years. We’re getting dangerously close to a 5-7 record team having to apply for a special waiver to play in a bowl game. That’s good news for Vanderbilt, not so good for the quality of the game.
DARST: There are too many bowls to begin. I could easily think of a few places that would probably support a bowl game with the right affiliations. Let’s think logically. It has to be easy to get to with a strong airport, it has to have a good base of hotels/resorts and there has to be things to do. The two cities that jump out to me are Indianapolis and Denver. Indianapolis has the new stadium. You can get there from just about anywhere and if you tie in the game with a Big Ten team, you are sure to get at least 40,000 people. Denver could work too if it had a Big 12 vs. Mountain West/WAC tie in. But please, no more bowl games.
Posted on March 17th, 2010 by admin
Filed under: College football news, NCAA college football | No Comments »
